Restaurants in Truth or Consequences, Elephant Butte & All of Sierra County

dinner, lunch, outdoor seating

A & B Drive-In

211 Broadway, 
Truth or Consequences

An old-fashioned downtown drive-in restaurant with burgers, shakes, tacos, enchiladas, burritos, BLTs, and shaved ice.

Open: 10am-8:45pm Mon-Tues-Wed, 10am-9pm Thurs-Fri-Sat, 11am-6:30pm Sun
more info
breakfast, dinner, lunch, outdoor seating

Arrey Cafe

New Mexico Highway 187, 

Authentic Mexican Food – local chile and fresh ingredients! The Arrey Cafe is the only place in Sierra County that serves fideo. Locals love the Friday night Ribeye special. Stop in for donuts made fresh each morning.

Open: 8am-4pm Mon-Tues-Wed-Thurs-Sat, 8am-8pm Fri, 8am-2pm Sun
more info
dinner, lunch, outdoor seating

Casa Taco

704 Highway 195, 
Elephant Butte

A variety of fresh-made tacos — fish, pork, shrimp, beef, calabacitas and more — plus burritos, quesadillas, fried mushrooms, desserts.

Open: 11am-9pm Mon-Tues-Thurs-Fri-Sat, 11am-6pm Sun
more info
breakfast, dinner, lunch

Del Taco

212 North Date, 
Truth or Consequences

Open 7 days, breakfast all day. American-style Mexican cuisine and American fast food favorites.

Open: 6am-12am Mon-Tues-Wed-Thurs-Fri-Sat-Sun
more info
breakfast, dinner, lunch, outdoor seating

El Faro

315 N. Broadway, 
Truth or Consequences

Tasty New Mexican food in downtown Truth or Consequences.

Open: 8am-8pm Mon-Tues-Wed-Fri, 8am-2pm Thurs-Sat
more info
breakfast, lunch, outdoor seating

Hillsboro General Store & Cafe

10697 Highway 152, 

A family style restaurant in a historical building decorated with antiques and memorabilia of the 1800s. Watch their Facebook for announcements about special evening meals.

Open: 8am-3pm Fri-Sat-Sun
more info
breakfast, dinner, lunch, outdoor seating

Johnny B’s

2260 N. Date Street, 
Truth or Consequences

Family owned and operated by Johnny and Jackie Baca. Delicious “Homerun Cooking” and friendly service.

Open: 7am-4pm Mon-Tues, 7am-8pm Wed-Thurs-Fri-Sat-Sun
more info
dinner, lunch, outdoor seating

La Cocina / Hot Stuff

1 Lakeway Drive, 
Truth or Consequences

Selected as a “New Mexico Treasure” by the New Mexico Department of Tourism. Serving Southern New Mexico since 1965.

Open: 11am-9pm Sun-Mon-Tues-Wed-Thurs, 11am-9:30pm Fri-Sat
more info
breakfast, lunch

Mexican Grill

719 S. Broadway, 

Burrito counter in the Fast Stop Convenience store – great breakfast burritos, mostly for takeout, seating is limited.

Open: 6am-1:30pm Mon-Tues-Wed-Thurs-Fri-Sat
more info
breakfast, dinner, lunch

Sunset Grill

1301 N. Date, 
Truth or Consequences

Now located in “uptown” T or C; enchiladas & stuffed sopapillas, burgers, breakfast.

Open: 9am-5pm Mon-Tues-Wed-Thurs-Fri
more info
breakfast, dinner, lunch

Tony’s Restaurant

1990 S. Broadway, 
Truth or Consequences

Delicious, authentic Mexican dishes plus menudo, taquitos, hamburgers, and more. Tasty chips & salsa.

Open: 8am-7pm Tues-Wed-Thurs-Fri, 8am-2pm Sat
more info

Restaurant Search

Restaurant Search
— Filters —


  • All
  • Truth or Consequences (24)
  • Elephant Butte (4)
  • Arrey (1)
  • Hillsboro (1)
  • Williamsburg (1)

Beverage Options

Beverage Options
  • beer (9)
  • wine (8)
  • coffee drinks (5)
  • full bar (3)

Days Open *

Days Open *
  • Monday (22)
  • Tuesday (23)
  • Wednesday (23)
  • Thursday (26)
  • Friday (28)
  • Saturday (26)
  • Sunday (21)
* Subject to change, verify by calling.


  • American (26)
  • Vegetarian (12)
  • Mexican (11)
  • Seafood (4)
  • Italian (3)
  • Asian (2)
Scroll to Top